5 Reasons I’ll Never Buy a Home
In expensive cities Like New York, it’s cheaper to rent housing than to buy, which is fine by me. I’ve never even considered buying a home. Here are five reasons why:
- A Home Means WORK! The second your pen hits that mortgage, your work commences. Weeks, months, and years of painting inside and out, of furnishing rooms and planting flowers and building additions and cleaning gutters and replacing windows and cutting down damaged trees and weeding weeds that laugh in your face when they return a week later. And let us not forget all that land you own that needs mowing in summer heat waves and shoveling in winter blizzards. It’s not that I’m against work. It’s that I hate boring circular work that goes round and round like a carousel — but without the fun.
- You can kiss Your Savings Toodle-oo! POOF — All those years of saving and sweat immediately shot down the own-a-house-tubes. On top of your down payment, you can count on transaction costs (inspections, legal costs, real estate agent, etc.) of 7% to 10% of the house’s price. Which can translate to $30,000 for a $300,000 home. Yike!
- You alone will support your Home’s Addiction: Like a drug addict, a home’s need for cash is voracious and never ending. Forget nickel and dime stuff. Have you priced a new furnace lately? A new roof? An updated kitchen? Well don’t, if you have a tendency to faint at astronomical costs barreling your way. As far as maintenance and repairs, some estimate it at 1% yearly of a home’s price. That’s $3,000 bucks a year for a $300,000 home if YOU’RE doing the work. More, if you’re hiring out.
- Hidden Problems: The place could look absolutely stunning and trouble free before you move in. But once all your stuff’s in that door — POW! How are you supposed to sleep with those neighborhood dogs howling their heads off all night long? And what’s the scoop on those oddballs next door who never turn their lights on at night. Satanic get-togethers? A bunch of suburban Miss Havisham’s? Pauper City? And what’s that sudden putrid smell in the neighborhood? Termites? Killer vapors from some factory somewhere? And yes, these vexing problems can pop up in rentals too, but at least in a rental you can clear out and escape far more easily.
- You’re shackled to Sticks and Bricks: What if you suddenly want out from your job or receive a smashing offer from a company thousands of miles away? Or feel just plain itchy and want to resettle in a fresh new atmosphere? And what if any of those things occur during a lousy housing market when getting out could lose you buckets of dough — not to mention tons of nail biting time trying to find a buyer. Being shackled to that pile of bricks and wood could mean adios to opportunity, freedom and peaceful sleep.
Or do you say phooey to all these negatives? You want a house of your own anyway.
More on Real Estate:
- Thoreau on Simplicity, Success and Stardust
- 20 Lowest Property Taxes in USA
- Top 10 US Cities for Renters
- Tiny Houses – Streamlined, Slick and Smart
- The Man who Built himself a House for Peanuts
- Five Highest and Lowest State Property Taxes in the USA per capita
- Happily Living Dirt Cheap in New York City


As an owner of a 1926 bungalow, I can attest to these facts!
But to us it’s worth it, we don’t regret the decision to purchase the house.
Oct.03, 2011 | 11:44 amI love your house. And if I ever DID buy one, it would resemble yours: compact, solidly built, lots of light, with pleasant outdoor living space. And rich dirt to grow beautiful flowers. Although for that, think I would need a talented gardener like Martin.
Oct.03, 2011 | 12:50 pmHi Pat, thank you for your lovely comment on my blog. I came back here to read your reply, and wow, thank you for the lovely house compliment. I couldn’t agree more that you need a guy like Martin who’s totally into fixing every little thing plus building stuff. I’d be dead meat without him!
Oct.04, 2011 | 11:31 amThe shackled thing is a downside, as well as the rest, but a condo is a reasonable compromise and is much better for these things. You do pay more money, but when you live in a city full of really old apartment buildings and where most new construction is in condos, it’s also a way to live somewhere clean and comfortable, while paying a similar price as you would have to rent.
Oct.19, 2011 | 10:45 pmHere in NYC I think Co-ops are more popular than condos, although I’m not very clear on the difference. Also some of the really great apartments are in older buildings: high ceilings, spacious rooms, solid construction with thick walls and zero noise coming through. But no matter what the economy is up to, the apt. market is ALWAYS super tight. Thanks for your comment and stopping by…
Oct.19, 2011 | 11:47 pmThese are excellent points the average first time home owner dosen’t have a clue about these things.
Dec.25, 2011 | 9:40 pmHi there. I think the biggest shock for first time home owners may be all the necessary maintenance involved for keeping a home in good shape. Maintenance that involves both money and a LOT of time for those doing the upkeep themselves. In a way homeowners become servants to their own property. Fine, if you’re aware of it and don’t mind going in…
Thanks for stopping in.
Dec.25, 2011 | 9:55 pmI’m a happily single retired woman who has owned 9 houses on my own in 3 states. I have no family, no help of any kind yet I’ve managed to keep up all these houses and sell them when I wanted to. I’ve had some less-than-great neighbors, and I’ve had good ones. Right now, I live in a small town in western Colorado in a small subdivision. We have no HOA, my annual prop. taxes are $1,000, I have my front yard landscaped with no-maintenance rock, and the backyard has a small lawn it takes me about 10 minutes to cut. My neighbors don’t bother me at all, and the few kids here are well behaved. I would hate to live in a condo or apartment. They’re for college kids or old ladies. I love my yard, 3-car garage, peace and quiet with no adjacent walls and the gorgeous mountain view out back. I’d have none of that in a multi-family dwelling which also charges you high rent or maintenance fees per month — money down the tube. Oh, and I have no mortgage because I’ve saved and put myself in that enviable position 19 years ago. Apparently I’ve done something right. Home ownership is still the only way to go for those responsible enough to handle it.
Mar.27, 2012 | 3:43 pmWelcome Marianna. Nice to have your input. For you, a house is clearly the way to go. I wonder how many people who have large lawns and high maintenance yards might be reconsidering their landscaping decisions. I have a friend who built himself a weekend country house and he landscaped it by throwing wild plant and flower seeds in the space between his house and the woods. Zero maintenance. And it’s lovely.
Mar.27, 2012 | 4:22 pmSSB: I did make one mistake buying a house in TX — it was a half acre and highly landscaped with trees, grass and flower beds. I was “married” to that property for two years until I sold and moved on. I enjoy some yardwork, but that place was way over the top, especially in the Texas heat. Buyers have to think things out before jumping in to what they think will be paradise. Income is a consideration too. That is, you can always hire a lawn service/snow removal if your budget allows it. Your friend’s home with the wildflowers sounds wonderful — like a storybook place.
Mar.27, 2012 | 4:53 pmThat’s a good point about buyers, especially first time home buyers — that they should thoroughly think things out before jumping in to what they think will be paradise.
And my friend’s house IS wonderful. The 2nd floor has glass exterior walls so it’s like you’re sitting in the treetops.
Mar.27, 2012 | 5:40 pm