Why Should I Put More Money in China?

Before the recent dive in the Chinese microcap market, I made a decent profit trading small (but profitable) Bulletin Board Chinese stocks. Tinkerbell style bookkeeping occurred in a few of these stocks (a given in the BB game) and I got smacked accordingly, but in the end made out okay. This past week that market appears to be coming to life again.
As I contemplate jumping onto that roller-coaster ride again, some events in China have been bothering me lately. Undeterred after being caught adulterating milk with melamine, a toxic chemical that increased their profits and killed Chinese babies, some of the guilty milk companies actually REPEATED their melamine poisoning once the initial outcry died down. The next troublesome event was the collapse of Chinese schools in the 2008 earthquake that killed thousands of students, yet left neighboring buildings still standing. Unlike those solidly constructed buildings, it turns out China’s shoddily constructed schools had never been designed to withstand quakes at the high end of the Richter Scale. Next comes a tidbit I just recently came across. Researchers found that a whopping 31% of Chinese scientific papers submitted to a national scientific journal in the last two years contained plagiarized material. That’s a LOT of cheating. Because the Chinese government advances careers based strictly on the number of papers published, the pressure to produce these papers is enormous, though it’s pretty much agreed no one reads them.
But the topper is the story of Liu Xiaobo, a Chinese dissident serving an 11-year jail sentence for advocating political reform, who was awarded this year’s Nobel Peace Prize. A writer and former professor who stood between Tiananmen Square students and the soldiers and tanks ready to blast them into oblivion, Liu was a major force in ending that stand off without a blood bath. Since then the government has stripped him of his job, jailed him on and off for twenty years, and silenced his voice in his own country. So crushing has their censorship been that few Chinese people in the street today even know who he is. Nor do they know he’s been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize since the government has blocked news of that “political tool of the west” In all media. When Liu’s friends arrived at a private celebration banquet the night his prize was announced, they were immediately arrested and hauled away.
Attempting to interview his wife, Liu Xia, at the couple’s home, foreign reporters were blocked by a wall of police. Though she was briefly transported to her husband’s jail 300 miles away to deliver the news, his wife has since been put under house arrest. And both her cell phone and Internet connection have (surprise) been cut.
For those making investment decisions based strictly on dollar signs, these events have little to zero significance. I find it hard, however, to keep overlooking the Chinese government’s suffocation of free speech when dealing with differing opinions, especially opinions suggesting a loosening of their power. Like Thomas Jefferson, Liu wrote a pro democracy paper calling for the expansion of freedom in his country and the end to one-party rule (modeling it in fact on Jefferson’s writing). But unlike Jefferson, who was applauded and honored for his contribution to his countrymen’s freedom, Liu was condemned, jailed and silenced.
What’s your take, if any, on this? How do you read what’s happening in China today?
Other Posts on China, Investing & Freedom:
- China’s Bodacious Traffic Straddling Bus
- China: Meat that glows in the Dark Perfectly Safe to Eat
- Stock Trading Suspended…Uh-oh!
- Liberty Quotes, Parades and Potato Salad


My days of speculating are over but even if they weren’t I would probably avoid investing in Chinese stocks. The issues you’ve listed are some of the reasons why I wouldn’t want to.
Oct.13, 2010 | 9:56 amHi Susan, always appreciate your input. As far as stock speculation goes, it’s only a small part of my overall financial picture.
Oct.13, 2010 | 10:20 amI think investing (and life) can get very complicated when you included moral issues like human rights in China. The Chinese have made it (partly) possible that we live in such abundance since they have been sending cheap goods our way for decades. 3/4 of Walmart or Target would be empty if we boycotted China. So, where does one draw the line?
Oct.17, 2010 | 6:19 amYou’re right, it is complicated. And because China itself has brought prosperity to its own people who were living in extreme poverty before, most Chinese people remain silent on moral issues regarding their leaders. Of course another reason they don’t speak out is they don’t want to suddenly disappear, as has just happened to the head of Mothers of Tiananmen Square who, with her husband has vanished and not been heard from since the roundup of activists after Liu Xiaobo was awarded the Nobel.
At this point China is far too entrenched in our economy to consider any boycott. I guess everyone has to draw their own personal line. But no matter where my line is drawn I have the luxury (unlike the Chinese) of speaking freely about it.
Oct.17, 2010 | 10:48 amWeeks later his wife still hasn’t been heard from. They’re saying she’s asking for her husband’s friends to pick up his nobel prize for him. Problem is a lot of them have been carted off and silenced too.
Oct.26, 2010 | 10:59 amSo successful is Chinese censorship that even weeks later, few Chinese know who was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize. And young people in their twenties don’t even know who Liu Xiaobo is.
Oct.26, 2010 | 1:32 pm